External USB Slim Recorders Comparison

Review Pages

1. Introduction / Haiway External ODD&HDD Device
2. Rodzone A11-SU3
3. Rioddas BT-638 (1st variation)
4. Amicool BT-686
5. Cocopa ECD813-Y
6. Pop-up ODD Device
7. Effelon ODD Device
8. Rioddas BT-638 (2nd variation)
9. HLDS PortableDVD
10. Comparison Of Specifications
11. CD Reading Performance
12. Writing Performance Test Methodology
13. Imation 52X CD-R
14. Maxell 52X CD-R
15. Maxell 52X PRINTABLE CD-R
16. PlexDisc 52X PRINTABLE CD-R
17. Ritek 52X CD-R
18. Verbatim 52X CD-R
19. DVD Reading Performance
20. DataWrite 16X DVD-R
21. HP 16X DVD-R
22. Maxell 16X DVD-R
23. No Brand 16X DVD-R
24. PlexDisc 16X DVD-R
25. TraxData 16X DVD-R
26. Verbatim 16X DVD-R
27. JVC 16X DVD+R
28. Maxell 16X DVD+R
29. Philips 16X DVD+R
30. Sony 16X DVD+R
31. Verbatim 16X DVD+R
32. Verbatim 8X DVD+R DL
33. Summary of Burning Results
34. Conclusion - Final Total Score

The next media comes from Verbatim 16X DVD+R with MCC 004 (000) media ID code.

All tested drives recognized the Verbatim 16X DVD+R media.

The Cocopa ECD813-Y (TSSTcorp SN-208AB) reached the first place with 5.81X average writing speed. After the burn process, we tried to read the burned disc with the same drive and wrote down their average reading speed.

The Pop-up (Optiarc AD-7560A) had the highest reading speed with 5.93X.... After many hours measuring all discs we have our burn quality results.

The drives with the lowest PIE/PIF error rates are expected to get higher score points even they burn slower a disc. After all we all want perfectly readable discs.

With the Verbatim 16X DVD+R media, the HLDS PortableDVD (HLDS GP96Y) managed to produce the lowest error rates among all tested drives so it got the first place with 7.80 points. The two bottom placed drives, doesn't produce good quality burns at all.