H L Data Storage Store Banner 970x90
Breaking News

SP Industrial Launches MEA3FEV0 SSD Series with BiCS5 for Edge AI Computing Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise Unveils Wi-Fi 6E Thermaltake Announces the Divider 370 and 170 TG ARGB Chassis TEAMGROUP Announces the First High-Performance Industrial DDR5 in 5,600MHz TERRAMASTER RELEASES NEW TOS 5 SYSTEM WITH HIGHER SECURITY

logo

  • Share Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
  • Home
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Forum
  • Legacy
  • About
    • Submit News

    • Contact Us
    • Privacy

    • Promotion
    • Advertise

    • RSS Feed
    • Site Map

Search form

HLDS portable DVD Android external Recorder

Jan 6,2021 0

10. DVD Reading Tests

 

Review Pages

1. Introduction
2. Retail Package
3. TrueDVD (Android TV)
4. Disc Link Platinum (Android TV)
5. Using the device with Mobile Phone/Tablet
6. TrueDVD (Amazon FireHD)
7. Disc Link Platinum (Amazon FireHD)
8. Drive Information/features
9. CD Reading Tests
10. DVD Reading Tests
11. CD-R Writing Tests
12. DVD Media Writing Strategy (DVD-R,DVD-RW,DVD+R,DVD+RW,DVD-RAM)
13. Memorex 16X DVD-R Media
14. Moser Baer India 16X DVD-R
15. Philips 16X DVD-R Media
16. RiDisc 16X DVD-R Media
17. Taiyo Yuden 16X DVD-R
18. Verbatim 16X DVD-R
19. DVD-R DL Quality
20. DataWrite DVD+R 16X Media
21. Verbatim (Mitsubishi Kagaru Media) DVD+R 16X Media
22. TDK DVD+R 16X Media
23. DVD+R DL Quality
24. Conclusion

 

For our DVD reading tests, we used a variety of ABEX Test Discs to measure the drive's performance.

ABEX TDR-820 (Single Sided Single Layer DATA)

The drive reads in CAV the disc, starts from 3.37X and ends at 8.26X.

ABEX TDR-840 (Single Sided Dual Layer DATA)

Again the drive reads the disc perfectly, it starts at 3.37X and ends at 8.16X. at both layers.

Accesstek PTP ROM-9 Test disc DATA

Again similiar resutls with another PTP DVD-9 test media.

Accesstek OTP ROM-9 Test disc DATA

No issues with OTP DVD-9 ROM media as well.

Matrix Movie (DVD-9 VIDEO Disc)

DVD-Video can be read at 2.9X average reading speed with a maximum of 4.0X, it seems that the drive has limited its "ripping" DVD-Video abilities.

 

- DVD Error Correction Discs

For all our DVD Quality Measurements we set reading speed for all media at 8X, while Jitter for LiteON drives set at 4X under the OptiDriveControl software. Some explanation for the below measaurents follows and in general users should look at the trend of the error rates, rather than actual numbers. Note that usually higher reading/scanning speeds give higher error rates as well.

PIE (Parity Inner Errors) - exist on all DVDs and are nothing unusal. Normally the error correction of the drive can handle this. This test counts how many errors in a continuous set of 8 blocks occur (pisum8). If too many PIEs occure in a matrix line, so that the error correction can not fit any more, it is called a PIF. The highest possible value for PIE sum is 1664. The maximum value based on the recordable DVD specification for 8 blocks is 280. This table is for beginners and only for approximate orientation - it should only show tendencies. This is not a generally valid stencil. The orientation values of the table rely on errors, which are consistently dristributed on the DVD. There are also no hard crossings between the border values of the quality areas.

    min            max         quality area  
        0           20       excellent
      21           99       very good
    100         280       good
    281       1664       bad

PIF (Parity Inner Failure) - means that there are too many PIEs , so that the error correction of the drive can't fix it any more. PIFs are counted separately for each block (pisum1). The highest possible value for PIF is 208, but the maximum value based on the recordable DVD specification for one block is 4.

POE (Parity Outer Error) can occur when the Parity Outer Layer is trying to correct Parity Inner Failure. The dvd spefications does not give any absolut value like it is known from PIF. If POEs can't be corrected this results in a Parity Outer Failure.

POF (Parity Outer Failure) are uncorrectable Parity Outer Errors. DVD specification doesn't allow any POF. They normally result in so called CRC errors - uncorrectable errors.

 

ABEX TDR-821 (Single Sided Single Layer Scratched Media)

The drive reports a perfect reading CAV curve. As it shows below, there are sveral PIE and PIF error correction (articificially placed) that is not a serious problem for the drive's error correction abilities. PIE error are kept low when the media is not scratched and got high peaks when the PIF errors are also high. No POF (unreadable area) reported.

Using another utility called QpxTool we have also similiar results even results are presented in logarithmic scale for better understanding the PIE/PIF error area

ABEX TDR-825 (Single Sided Single Layer Defect Media)

The drive doesn't seem to have any problem with the TDR-825 disc, it shows a perfect reading CAV curve as well. The reported PIE/PIF values doesnt affect the reading speed, since all error are being corrected from the drive's internal error correction/

 

ABEX TDR-841 (Single Sided Dual Layer Scratch Media)

Using the ABEX TDR-841 media, we got very good reading speeds. The drive does report back several PIE/PIF errors but as expected doesnt seem to affect the drive's performance at all.

 

ABEX TDR-845 (Single Sided Dual Layer Defect Media)

The drive has excellent reading curves for both layers. The PIE/PIF scan doesnt show significant errors through the whole surface.

 

ABEX TDV-541 (Single Sided Dual Layer Scratch Media)

The TDV-541 disc seems to struggle the drive with serious speed dropdowns after the 3.0GB till 5.0GB, where all the articial scratches are placed. This also was confirmed from the disc quality test as well.

The QpxTool scan seems to stopped after starting the second layer...

 

ABEX TDV-545 (Single Sided Dual Layer Defect Media)

As happened with the TDV-545 test disc, the drive after 3.5GB till 4.5GB, due to the high articial errors present on the disc, forced to lower its reading speed to read the contents. At the disc quality test, the drive lowers its reading speed after the 4.0GB mark towards the end of the disc.

 

Summary of Testing pressed DVD/DVD-Video defect/scratched media discs

Error Correction Test
Media
Reading Speed (Average)
PIE Errors (Average)
PIF Errors (Average)
POF Errors
Almedio TDR-821
5.84X
10.52
1.18
0
Almedio TDR-825
5.84Χ
5.44
0.50
0
Almedio TDR-841
5.76Χ
17.12
1.27
0
Almedio TDR-845
5.76X
11.69
0.44
0
Almedio TDV-541
4.97X
24.73
1.87
0
Almedio TDV-545
5.48X
14.41
0.44
0

From the above tests, it seems that the HLDS portableDVD drive is capable of high error correction, since managed to perform very well in all of our tests, even had to drop reading speed with some test discs. The reported errors are kept in managed levels and the drive will not have serious issues reading even slight scratched media.

 

Review Pages

1. Introduction
2. Retail Package
3. TrueDVD (Android TV)
4. Disc Link Platinum (Android TV)
5. Using the device with Mobile Phone/Tablet
6. TrueDVD (Amazon FireHD)
7. Disc Link Platinum (Amazon FireHD)
8. Drive Information/features
9. CD Reading Tests
10. DVD Reading Tests
11. CD-R Writing Tests
12. DVD Media Writing Strategy (DVD-R,DVD-RW,DVD+R,DVD+RW,DVD-RAM)
13. Memorex 16X DVD-R Media
14. Moser Baer India 16X DVD-R
15. Philips 16X DVD-R Media
16. RiDisc 16X DVD-R Media
17. Taiyo Yuden 16X DVD-R
18. Verbatim 16X DVD-R
19. DVD-R DL Quality
20. DataWrite DVD+R 16X Media
21. Verbatim (Mitsubishi Kagaru Media) DVD+R 16X Media
22. TDK DVD+R 16X Media
23. DVD+R DL Quality
24. Conclusion

 

Pages

  • « first
  • ‹ previous
  • …
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • …
  • next ›
  • last »

HLDS

Andoird

Tags: HLDS Andoird
Previous Post
Whats best for you MAC or PC?
Next Post
Crucial X6 2TB portable SSD

Related Posts

  • CDRInfo.com (p)reviews the HLDS UD Station

  • HLDS UD Station DVDRW (Preview)

  • External USB Slim Recorders Comparison

  • HLDS presents the world first DVD which is compatible with Android OS to fascinate customers

  • European Court Dismissed Optical Storage Makers' Appeal in Cartel Case

  • You Can Now Claim Get A $10 Settlement Following An Optical Disk Drive Antitrust Ligitation

  • Hitachi-LG Data Storage Joins Microsoft’s Windows Rally Program

  • HLDS, TSST Face EU Antitrust Fines

H L Data Storage Store Banner 300x600

 

Latest Reviews

10 Top Majors for Students Who Aren't Sure
Consumer Electronics

10 Top Majors for Students Who Aren't Sure

AI Completely Mastered Poker
Enterprise & IT

AI Completely Mastered Poker

Noctua NH-D12L CPU Cooler
Cooling Systems

Noctua NH-D12L CPU Cooler

EnGenius ECW230 Access Point
Enterprise & IT

EnGenius ECW230 Access Point

What Are The Similarities Between The Metaverse And The Matrix?
Enterprise & IT

What Are The Similarities Between The Metaverse And The Matrix?

Popular News

Samsung Releases New Flash Laptop

Samsung Releases New Flash Laptop

Facebook Unveils New Technology to Fight Child Exploitation

Facebook Unveils New Technology to Fight Child Exploitation

Samsung's Next Smartphone foray: Galaxy S10, 5G, Folding Phones

Samsung's Next Smartphone foray: Galaxy S10, 5G, Folding Phones

YouTube to Invest $20m in Educational Creators

YouTube to Invest $20m in Educational Creators

Twitter's Ad Sales Surge

Twitter's Ad Sales Surge

Samsung HMD Odyssey+ Mixed Reality Headset Comes WithTwo 3.5-inch AMOLED Displays

Samsung HMD Odyssey+ Mixed Reality Headset Comes WithTwo 3.5-inch AMOLED Displays

Japanese Wireless Carriers to Cut iPhone XR Price: report

Japanese Wireless Carriers to Cut iPhone XR Price: report

Google To Deliver Personalized Audio News Lists Through AI Assistant

Google To Deliver Personalized Audio News Lists Through AI Assistant

  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Forum
  • Legacy
  • About
    • Submit News

    • Contact Us
    • Privacy

    • Promotion
    • Advertise

    • RSS Feed
    • Site Map
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Promotional Opportunities @ CdrInfo.com
  • Advertise on out site
  • Submit your News to our site
  • RSS Feed