Breaking News

Geometric Future Introduces the Eskimo Ultra 42 AIO and Squama Ultimate 3003-14 Fans Arctic announces PX-1 thermal putty pad series Flowtica Verso AI Productivity Companion Launches for Preorder at Special Early-Bird Price DeepCool Launches StationX 622 High-Performance Cooling for Professional Workstations SSSTC Introduces PCIe Gen4 QLC SSDs for AI PCs and Industrial Applications

logo

  • Share Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
  • Home
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Essays
  • About
    • Submit News

    • Contact Us
    • Privacy

    • Promotion
    • Advertise

    • RSS Feed

Search form

Patent System Questionned in eBay Case

Patent System Questionned in eBay Case

Enterprise & IT Mar 30,2006 0

In the eBay versus MercExchange case, some U.S. Supreme Court justices suggested on Wednesday that the patent at the heart of the suit may be too vague and trivial to even be taken seriously. Patent holder and small U.S, technology firm, MercExchange sued eBay in September 2001, accusing it of patent infringement through the "Buy it Now" feature, which allows shoppers to stop the auction process and purchase items at a fixed price.

A federal appeals court sided with MercExchange and granted it an injunction against eBay. The injunction is currently on hold as online auction house eBay is threatened to have one of its core services to shut down.

During the oral argument at the Supreme Court, chief Justice John Roberts drew laughter from the court audience when he made a quip about his interpretation of MercExchange's patent.

"It's displaying pictures of your wares on a computer monitor and picking the ones you want. I might be able to do that.It's very vague." he said.

eBay argues that judges should be able to deny injunctions in patent cases and instead choose to fine the perpetrator. The current threat of having their services immediately closed down if they are found guilty of patent abuse is unfair, according to the company.

It further adds that it leaves large technology companies such as itself open to victimisation and attack from small "patent trolls", who use the threat of immediate shutdown orders to force out-of-court settlements for huge sums of money.

Not all justices expressed skepticism about the patent though. Justice Antonin Scalia for instance, questioned eBay's argument that companies should be treated differently if they don't actually use the patents they own in business just like MercExchange.

"Why should we draw a distinction between the solo inventor who needs a patent speculation firm to market his invention and somebody else?" Scalia asked. "We're talking about a property right here, and a property right is the exclusive right to exclude others. That's what a patent right is ... give me my property back."

The lawsuit is part of a broader debate over the future of the U.S. patent system,involving the software and pharmaceutical industries as a verdict in favour of eBay would set a new precedent.

ebay claims that since the first 2003 court case it has sufficiently altered its "Buy it Now" tool to avoid breaching MercExchange's patents, but it remains to be seen what will be the final verdict of the Supreme Court that scheduled for June.

Tags: eBay
Previous Post
Double Layer DVD+RW Media Closer to Production
Next Post
Volume Limits on New iPod Software

Related Posts

  • Starboard Ends Proxy Fight at eBay

  • eBay Launches “Up & Running” To Bring Small Businesses Online

  • eBay to Begin Managing Payments in the United Kingdom

  • EBay in Talks on Deal for Classifieds Business

  • Intercontinental Says Not Interested for EBay Any More

  • Intercontinental Exchange Targets eBay Acquisition: WSJ

  • Facebook and eBay Pledge to Combat Fake Reviews

  • Organization Identifies Implications of BigTech's Engagement in Financial Data

Latest News

Geometric Future Introduces the Eskimo Ultra 42 AIO and Squama Ultimate 3003-14 Fans
Cooling Systems

Geometric Future Introduces the Eskimo Ultra 42 AIO and Squama Ultimate 3003-14 Fans

Arctic announces PX-1 thermal putty pad series
Cooling Systems

Arctic announces PX-1 thermal putty pad series

Flowtica Verso AI Productivity Companion Launches for Preorder at Special Early-Bird Price
Consumer Electronics

Flowtica Verso AI Productivity Companion Launches for Preorder at Special Early-Bird Price

DeepCool Launches StationX 622 High-Performance Cooling for Professional Workstations
Cooling Systems

DeepCool Launches StationX 622 High-Performance Cooling for Professional Workstations

SSSTC Introduces PCIe Gen4 QLC SSDs for AI PCs and Industrial Applications
Enterprise & IT

SSSTC Introduces PCIe Gen4 QLC SSDs for AI PCs and Industrial Applications

Popular Reviews

Endorfy Thock V2 Wireless Keyboard

Endorfy Thock V2 Wireless Keyboard

SoundPeats Cove Pro

SoundPeats Cove Pro

The Quiet Technology Behind the Spin

The Quiet Technology Behind the Spin

Akaso Brave 8 Lite

Akaso Brave 8 Lite

SoundPeats C30

SoundPeats C30

Kioxia Exceria Plus G3 512GB microSD

Kioxia Exceria Plus G3 512GB microSD

be quiet! Dark Perk Mice

be quiet! Dark Perk Mice

XbotGo Chamaleon

XbotGo Chamaleon

Main menu

  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Essays
  • About
    • Submit News

    • Contact Us
    • Privacy

    • Promotion
    • Advertise

    • RSS Feed
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Contact Us
  • Promotional Opportunities @ CdrInfo.com
  • Advertise on out site
  • Submit your News to our site
  • RSS Feed