Destroyer123
Posts: 32
Joined: 2/3/2003 From: USA Status: offline
|
quote: Originally posted by Demodave I tried several things with Plextor to fix this problem and was ultimately told that the media recommeded on their website isn't compatible with my Plextor burner. Here are the e-mail exchanges: quote: I am having a problem burning audio CD's. The very beginning of the disc is difficult for some home CD players to read with lots of static and clicking. Farther into the disc, the problem goes away and the disc plays fine. I used to have a Plextor 16X burner and never had a problem with the burned CD's. I bought two Plextor PX-W4824A drives and upgraded both to latest firmware of v1.04 and both have the exact same problem on two different computers. I tried the diagnostic mode on the drive and it reported no problems. Here is the setup on my home computer: * Pentium III 800 MHz on a motherboard with an Intel chipset * 2 Maxtor hard drives on the Primary IDE chain * Plextor PX-W4824A on the Secondary IDE master * Lite-On DVD drive on the Secondary IDE slave * Windows XP Professional Edition * Nero Burning ROM The work computer is similar except that it has a Pentium 4 1.4 GHz processor and is running Windows 2000. The media I use is top-notch....Mitsui Silver and TY Silver disc. I have read about others with this same problem from other users on the various CD-R internet forums, but have never seen a solution posted. I have attached the text file output from Nero's Info Tool from my home system, which will give you every detail of my system including the serial number of my Plextor drive. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!! --Dave Martin _________________________________________ From: Plextor Support Team support@plextor.com Date: Tue, 20 May 2003 11:00:22 -0700 Subject: RE: PX-W4824A Problem Nothing in your message here describes the 'problem' very well. What is the EXACT error message you get? Most often noise on a disc is from the disc media or the eide settings on your computer. You may have to experiment a bit to find out which media works best with your CD player. Plextor America Support Team - Jack ____________________________________ From: demodave@xxxx.com Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 2003 11:40 AM To: support@plextor.com Subject: RE: PX-W4824A Problem I'll try to explain the problem a bit better... When burning an audio CD, I get a static sound / skipping at the beginning of the CD. The Plextor will play it back fine, but three different audio CD players have problems with the burned discs. This problem happens with two different kinds of media: TY 48 disc and Mitsui Silver discs. Both of these are considered the best available and are recommended on your website. I used to burn CD's with a Plextor 16/10/40a IDE burner and never once did I have a problem...a perfect burn every time. All three of the mentioned home CD players never had a problem with discs burned with the older Plextor. I also borrowed a Lite On 48 burner from a friend and the burns were perfect and played back everywhere. I just have the problem with the new Plextors. I have DMA enabled on all IDE channels....I have tried installing Intel's Application Accelerator (and un-installing it) with no luck. I have read about others who have had this same problem on some of the internet forums. Is the first time anyone has ever brought this particular problem up to Plextor support? From your message below, it seems that the media choice is not good....what should I use then? I am using what is considered the best media available. This same media always worked fine on the Plextor 16/10/40a. Is it possible that there is a flaw on both of my Plextor PX-W4842A drives? They were purchased thru Amazon at the same time. If there is no solution to this problem, can I upgrade the drives to the new Premium Plextors and pay the difference in cost? I burn CD's of radio commercials for clients and cannot take the chance that they might not play correctly in their players. Thank you again for your assistance. ______________________________________ From: Plextor Support Team support@plextor.com Date: Tue, 20 May 2003 12:46:31 -0700 Subject: RE: PX-W4824A Problem Plextor has no 'upgrade' plan to change drives. No CDR drive manufacturer does... What would we do with older drives?? The only time we've run into this problem is with either an eide controller problem, or a media issue. Changing to different media is a good idea, as is putting the DMA jumper on the back of the drive to put it into multiword dma mode and/or updating the eide controller drivers. You can also try burning at a slower speed or use a different version of CDR software to see what that does, too. Plextor America Support Team - Jack _______________________________________ From: demodave@xxxx.com Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 2003 2:18 PM To: support@plextor.com Subject: RE: PX-W4824A Problem I have used the DMA jumper....no change. I upgraded the drivers for my IEDE controller....no change. I upgraded the bios on my Gateway to the very newest version....no change. I tried cheaper Memorex 48x rated media....no change. Once again, most CD players will play back these discs fine. But a few CD players, including a professional Denon and a professional Marantz will not play discs made with this new Plextor. I can't take the chance that the client's CD player won't play his new commercial. This is precisely why I spent the extra money on Plextor drives over a Lite On; along with the fact that my old Plextor 16x burner never once burned a coaster. Do you have any other suggestions? _____________________________________ From: Plextor Support Team support@plextor.com Date: Tue, 20 May 2003 15:30:51 -0700 Subject: RE: PX-W4824A Problem Well, Memorex media never works properly, so I expect that to fail! This is very typical of a media problem, as we've said before. This doesn't appear to be a drive issue at all. What would you like us to do? Plextor America Support Team - Jack ___________________________________________________ From: demodave@xxxx.com Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 2003 3:33 PM To: support@plextor.com Subject: RE: PX-W4824A Problem I agree. Memorex is not a brand I normally ever use. Can you recommend some different media to use? So far, I have purchased Mitsui Silver CD-R's (MIT200) and TAIYO YUDEN Silver CD-R's (TY800-48x) from National Audio Company. I have also used Fuji 48x certified CD-R's (made by TAIYO YUDEN). They all exhibit the same problem. These are all highly recommended from your own website. Why does my older Plextor 16/10/40A and a newer Lite On 48x burner not have any problems with this exact same media? I feel like I flushed $200 down the drain if the PX-W4824A is truly that finicky of a drive, since I purchased two of them. Plus I have recommended Plextor's to quite a few people. ________________________________________________ From: Plextor Support Team <support@plextor.com> Subject: RE: PX-W4824A Problem Date: Tue, 20 May 2003 16:39:04 -0700 Are you having the same problem with both of the 48/24/48 drives? If so, then it's got to be something other than the drive itself. I've never used the Taiyo Yuden silver discs, only their gold ones. I also use a lot of Verbatim and have no problems at all with them. Plextor America Support Team - Jack
Am I not explaining things well enough to Plextor? Am I expecting too much from this drive to have it work properly from the above mentioned media? If the 48/24/48 drives are really that finicky, I can't afford to use them. Anyone else have any ideas?
Demodave: I believe your problem is with faulty 48/24/48A drives. You may wish to double check IDE connections and check if there are options in the BIOS which (if changed) may solve the problem. You have easily convinced me that your problem is not the media! You could, if you *wish* test the drive with Verbatim DataLifePlus Super Azo 48X certified media--this is the media that Plextor ships with all their newer Plextor 48/24/48A drives. Also, their Premium drive ships with the exact same media, except that it is the 52X certified Verbatim DataLifePlus Super Azo. What firmware are you using? Make sure you are using the latest 1.04 firmware, and also try burning at lower speeds. Lowering the speeds is not a solution, since lowering the speed just avoids the problem, and I would not accept that as a solution, if I were you. However, lowering the speeds may work for you as a temporary work around. You may wish to experiment with firmware versions other than 1.04 to see if that helps, too. I found, in my experience with the 48/24/48A drive, that it is a poor quality buggy drive with a lot of problems. I went through 3 of the 48/24/48A drives, and this was for a *single* drive upgrade. The first drive was excessively loud (much louder than my Liteon DVD-ROM drive), and the second two had intermittent problems full erasing/writing to Verbatim Ultra Speed CD-RW discs. I gave up after the third drive and demanded a refund from Plextor! And I got that refund! I tried everything, including the diagostic test, the DMA jumper, etc. BTW, before Plextor will return your drive, you should do the diagnostic self test listed in the manual, but don't believe that if it passes that the drive is good! I had a lot of lousy support from Plextor like you did, including a lot of email support from Jack! That's right, the same guy you are communicating with. His support is terrible--he has an attitude problem and he will never admit that there is a problem with the Plextor hardware! He always blames the media or the eide setup or something else, but never the Plextor hardware. I can tell after reading his emails to you that he hasn't gotten any better! Demodave: can you return these drives to the vendor you bought them from? If you are beyond the return time frame (often 30 days), then you need special help. You really don't want another two 48/24/48A drives, because you are likely to run into the same problem with them! I got my refund (after the 30 days the store allowed me to return it) by going through a process with the Director of Engineering at Plextor America. First, I would try the phone support, if you don't get anywhere with them, post back here and I will give you Director of Engineering's contact info. He will want to test the drive to try to find where the problem is and will want to give you a replacement, and if the replacement drive doesn't work any better for you, he'll give you a refund! Only go this route if you have given phone support a shot. One other thing: the Plextor Premium drive did solve this problem for one user who returned the 48/24/48A and bought a Premium drive. It is my belief that the Premium drive (besides its many more features) provides traditional Plextor quality and would work for you if you want to trust Plextor again. But, I couldn't go that route, since the Plextor Premium wasn't out after I got my refund for the 48/24/48A. I now have a Liteon made TDK 52/24/48 and couldn't be happier. If I needed to buy a CD-RW drive now, I still would not buy a Plextor Premium drive, because Plextor ticked me off so highly that I may not ever be able to trust them again.
|