1. Introduction
Pioneer
DVR-A04 DVD-R/RW - Page 1
- Introduction
The
DVR-A03 made many users dream for a true low-price DVD-R recorder. The DVR-A03
was a best seller in many countries and now Pioneer is ready to ship its fourth-generation
DVD-R recorder under the codename "DVR-A04". The new model doesn't
offer what most users would wish for, "4x DVD-R recording speed",
but it does have several improvements over the DVR-A03. We compared, side by
side, the "old" DVR-A03 and the "new" DVR-A04.
- New features
The
desired "4x DVD-R writing speed" is not yet present, but as Pioneer
says there have been several improvements:
1) Drive length has been shortened by 1cm
2) Both horizontal + vertical mounting is possible
3) Increased read speed for DVD-Rom - was 4X, now 6X
4) Digital Audio connector removed - Analog only
5) Front bezel / LED indicator changed
6) Buffer Underrun Free for CD-R/CD-RW
7) Lower Fan Noise - sleeve bearing instead of ball bearing
8) Shorten format time for DVD-RW format (only 2minutes)
- Main Features
The drive supports almost all-available CD and DVD formats including HS-CD/RW:
Writing Speeds
|
Reading Speeds
|
DVD-R: 2X-CLV (2.770 MB/s), 1X-CLV
(1.385 MB/s)
DVD-RW (both v1.0/1.1): 1X-CLV (1.385 MB/s)
CD-R: 8X-CLV (1.20 MB/s), 4X-CLV (0.60 MB/s)
CD-RW: 4X (0.60 MB/s) * limited to 4x for HS-CD/RW
|
DVD-ROM (Single): 6-CAV (5.540 MB/s)
DVD-ROM (Dual): 2X-CLV (2.770 MB/s)
DVD-R, DVD-RW: 2X-CLV (2.770 MB/s)
CD-ROM, CD-R, CD-RW, CDDA: Max. 24X-CAV (3.60MB/s)
Video-CD: 4X-CLV (0.60MB/s) |
In short, the drive supports 8x writing (CD), 4x re- writing (CD)* limited
to 4x for HS-CD/RW, 24x reading (CD), 1x/2x writing (DVD), 1x re-writing (DVD),
and 6x reading (DVD). The drive's buffer is 2MB and includes "buffer underrun
protection" for both CD and DVD formats (another improvement over the DVR-A03)!
With the DVD-R format, only DAO and Packet Writing modes are supported. Lastly,
the drive doesn't support RAW writing with either CD or DVD formats.
- The package
We
received an engineering sample of the Pioneer DVR-A04. The retail version of
the drive will come under the codename "DVR-A04". The OEM model will
be named "DVR-104". The retail box will included: The drive itself,
multilingual operating instructions (7 languages), 5 pieces of Pioneer 74min
CD-R media, 2 pieces of Pioneer 4.7GB DVD-R "General use" media, mounting
screws, configuration pin jumper, forced eject key and a Staedler Lumocolor
pen.
The drive came without any software but the retail package is planned to include
VOB's Instant CD/DVD v6.4 and Sonic Solution's MyDVD v3.0. The drive will become
available world-wide at the beginning of April 2002. The price of the drive
is not yet known, but for sure it would be lower than the current DVR-A03 price.
After a quick search over Pricewatch.com, we saw that the lowest price for Pioneer
DVR-104 (bare drive) is around 338$ (380 Euros), while the DVR-A04 costs 375$
(425 Euros). Prices of DVD-R media ,branded, starts from 8$ (Pioneer) and un-branded
from 2$ (Princo).
In different regions, other packages could be available. For example, Pioneer
Australia offers 3 different retail kits , with different DVD Authoring software
and with even Firewire PCI card.
The front of the drive did not include the "Pioneer" logo (retail
models will do so). However, it did display the "DVD-R/RW" and "HS-RW"
logos. There is one LED present, as well as the eject button and the headphone
input jack/volume selector. The exact colours for the "Read/Write"
LED are: "Green" during reading. "Orange" during writing,
and when an error occurs it blinks "Orange". For the "Disc"
LED, it blinks "Green" when the tray is opened or closed. When a read
only disc is loaded it lights "Green". When a recordable disc is loaded
it lights "Orange". When an unsupported disc is loaded it blinks "Orange":
On the back of the drive there are the usual connectors: IDE interface, power,
the jumpers for setting the drive as a Master/Slave, the analog output connector
and a 2.7cm built-in fan for keeping the drive temperature low. (Don't forget
that DVD-R recording produces higher temperatures than CD-R recording).
- Installation
The Pioneer DVR-A04 was installed as a Master in the secondary IDE BUS.
The drive worked in UDMA33 mode and after rebooting, it identified itself as
a "Pioneer DVD-RW DVR-104". Under WinXP DMA was activated automatically.
The drive was a 2001 model with firmware v1.10 installed. After our tests
finished, Pioneer released a newer firmware version (v1.20).
There is a also a region free firmware for those who make frequent changes to
the region of the drive. Note that this firmware
is not officiall!
We used Nero Burning ROM (5.5.7.2), Ahead InCD (3.21), CloneCD (3.3.4.1)
and Sonic Solution's MyDVD v3.0 for the CD/DVD recording/authoring tests.
2. CD/DVD Data Tests
Pioneer
DVR-A04 IDE DVD-R/RW - Page
2
CD/DVD Data Tests
- SCSI Mechanic v3.0x results
The Pioneer DVR-A04 has almost the same performance as the previous DVR-A03
drive. Both drives support 24x (CAV) maximum reading speed. The Pioneer DVR-A04
seems improved at the "Average Random I/O" mark with 647Kb/s. At the
"Average Sequential I/O" mark, the drive is slower than DVR-A03 by
only 3Kb/s.
- Pressed CD: (Click
to see the CD Speed Graph)
Using Nero CD Speed v0.85, we confirmed the SCSI Mechanic results. The Pioneer
DVR-A04 drive has an 18.61X average reading speed, which is slightly lower than
the previous DVR-A03 drive.
In the "Seek Times" test, the Pioneer DVR-A04 has the same performance
as with DVR-A03 at "Random" and "1/3" tests. There is a
noticeable improvement in the "Full Stroke" test. The DVR-A04 resulted
in 297ms, whilst the DVR-A03 is 376ms
- CDR Media: (Click
to see the CD Speed graph)
With CD-R media, the Pioneer DVR-A04 drive has improved performance and has
a 19.01X average reading speed. The Pioneer DVR-A03 drive stays at 12.71X.
- HS-RW Media: (Click
to see the CD Speed graph)
Pioneer DVR-A04 has improved the reading performance also with HS-CD/RW media,
giving a 19.16X reading speed. Pioneer DVR-A03 stays behind with 12.37X.
- DVD Results: (Click to see the DVD Speed graph for DVD-ROM,
DVD-R,
DVD-RW,
DVD+RW)
Pioneer DVR-A04 supports a DVD reading speed of 6X (X factor = 1385Kb/s)
and the test results show that clearly. Pioneer DVR-A03 stays behind with a
4X DVD reading speed.
The seek times of Pioneer DVR-A04 are the same as for the DVR-A03 model,
in the "Random" test. In the "1/3" and "Full Stroke"
tests, the DVR-A04 gave almost the half seek times than the DVR-A03.
When ripping DVD movies, the Pioneer DVR-A04 has an average reading speed
of 2750Kb/s. The performance is confirmed by the specifications, since the drive
can only read up to 2X with dual layer DVD's. Compared to Pioneer DVR-A03, the
performance has increased slightly.
Pioneer DVR-A04 supports 2X CLV for all DVD formats, including DVD-R/DVD-RW
and DVD+RW .The performance of the drive is higher than Pioneer's DVR-A03, since
it supported 2X CLV (DVD-R) and 1X CLV (DVD-RW) reading speeds*. Note that both
Pioneer DVR-A03/A04 cannot recognize written DVD+R media as the last minute
tests showed.
* NB: This is dependent on the state of the DVD-RW media. If it has been
finalized, then it should be able to be read at 2X. If it is still in an un-finalized
state, then the R4 stays in 1X read mode for un-finalized media because it remains
in a "Write ready" state.
3. CloneCD reading Tests
Pioneer
DVR-A04 IDE DVD-R/RW - Page
3
CloneCD Reading
Tests
- Procedure
We used CloneCD (v3.3.4.1) and 5 original CDs - Euro 2000 (SafeDisc 1), No
One Lives For Ever (SafeDisc 2), Rally Masters (LaserLock 1), Desperados (LaserLock
2) and V-Rally 2 Expert (SecuROM 2) - in order to test the reading performance
of the Pioneer DVR-A04. We also tested its reading performance with backups
of the original CDs, since the reading speed varies between the original and
the backup media. The following pictures show reading/writing capabilities for
both drives:
- SafeDisc 1/2 results
Both DVR-A03/A04 drives are not the best choice for reading SD1/2 protected
CDs. The DVR-A04 drive seems slightly improved over the DVR-A03 drive.
- LaserLock 1/2 results
In the LaserLock 1/2 protected CDs tests, Pioneer DVR-A04's is not too fast
and users should really use another drive for such reading tasks.
- SecuROM results
Pioneer DVR-A04 can only read 16bytes (and not 96bytes) of SubChannel data
from Data/Audio tracks. This means that you can backup SecuROM 2 CDs but not
LibCrypt PSX protected titles, in case you use the DVR-A04 as the main reader.
4. DAE Tests
Pioneer
DVR-A04 IDE DVD-R/RW - Page
4
DAE Tests
- Test Method
We used CD DAE 99 v0.3 beta and EAC v0.9 beta 2 software in order to check
the DAE performance of the drive with various AudioCDs (both pressed and CDR).
The posted DAE results are the average of both applications. We made a full
CD Rip starting from the first to the last track of the CD. The Average DAE
reported speeds are displayed in the test graphs.
-
DAE features
As the EAC reports, the Pioneer DVR-A04 supports "Caching" data,
"Accurate Stream", but doesn't support "C2 error info".
- Pressed AudioCD results
The Pioneer DVR-A04 has increased the reading performance up to 24x (CAV).
That's a major improvement over the previous DVR-A03. The average reading speed
is now 16.2X:
- CDR AudioCD Results
The Pioneer drive has slightly lower reading performance with CDR media than
with pressed CDs:
- EAC Secure Extract Ripping mode
After many requests from numerous visitors we have added the
EAC's secure extract ripping mode results, which ensures maximum produced WAV
quality. Note that for each drive we used the build-in detection function:
Tested Drives
|
Average DAE Speed (X)
|
Pressed
|
CDR
|
Pioneer DVR-A03
|
1.6
|
1.6
|
Pioneer DVR-A04
|
4.5
|
4.6
|
- Advanced DAE Quality
All drives performed excellently in the Nero CD Speed Advanced DAE quality
test. Pioneer DVR-A04 produced "0" data/sync errors and got a perfect
score (100). As the Nero CD Speed Advanced DAE test showed, the drive can read
"CD-Text" and "SubChannel Data" from Audio tracks:
- Bad CDR Media results
Despite the fact that Nero CD Speed Advanced DAE test stretches
a drive's mechanism to the max, we decided to do real life tests with a scratched
disc. The disc was dirty, and with some light scratches, enough to cause problems
to most of the tested drives. We used CD DAE 99 software to rip the whole disc
(756539616 sectors) and the results were very interesting:
|
Average Speed (X)
|
Errors
|
Errors Of Total Disc (%)
|
Pioneer DVR-A03
|
7.0
|
68804154
|
9.09
|
Pioneer DVR-A04
|
17.2
|
11428546
|
1.51
|
As the tests proved, Pioneer DVR-A04 does perform well with scratched CDs.
The drive reported many reading errors though, but the final % of the total
disc is low, compared to the DVR-A03's results.
- Ripping 90 and 99mins AudioCDs
The drive can read both 90/99min CDs without any problems.
- Reading/Ripping Protected AudioCDs
For the test procedure we used 3 protected AudioCDs, which we
tested in both recognition and ripping (with CD DAE v0.3b/EAC v0.9 beta2) processes:
* Pressed AudioCD with Sony Key2Audio
* Pressed AudioCD with Cactus Data Shield 200 (Natalie Imbruglia - White Lilies
Island)
|
Key2Audio
|
CDS200
|
CDDAE
|
EAC
|
CDDAE
|
EAC
|
Pioneer DVR-104
|
Cannot recognize disc contents
|
Cannot recognize disc contents
|
The Pioneer DVR-A04 drive cannot recognize the contents of protected Audio
discs.
5. CDR Tests
Pioneer
DVR-A04 IDE DVD-R/RW - Page
5
CDR Tests
Pioneer DVR-A04 supports 4x and 8x (CLV) writing. The drive does support
buffer underrun protection for CD and DVD formats which is useful for today's
applications. We did our tests with Nero v5.5.7.8 and CloneCD v3.3.4.1. For
the CD-R tests we used: Creation 74min (12x), Taiyo Yuden 74 & 80min (24x),
Mitsui 74min (24 & 16x) and Verbatim/TDK 74min HS-RW media.
- CD-R Tests
We created a "DataCD" job with data slightly higher than 74mins
(74:03:65). We burned the same job with both tested drives, using the same media:
Pioneer DVR-A04 needs 601secs to finish the task, which is actually a higher
writing time than the DVR-A03. (Future firmware upgrades will most likely not
improve this speed).
- 80min CDs
Following the same procedure as in the previous test, we created a DataCD
with data lower than 80min (79:49:50). The Pioneer DVR-A04 supports overburning
but needs 10 more seconds to end the task, compared to the DVR-A03:
- Writing Quality Tests
We used Ritek 74min CD-R 16x certified media and wrote a full 74min CD. All
CDs were burned with the latest Nero version. The produced CDs were measured
from DigitalDrives and the test
results illustrated at the following table:
8x writing speed
|
Model
|
C1
|
Average Burning Time (secs)
|
Max
|
Average
|
Pioneer DVR-104
|
14
|
0,6
|
601
|
The Pioneer DVR-A04 produced a very low C1 error rate with the Ritek media.
The following graph illustrates the C1 error rate over the whole disc area:
- Overburning Tests
Our attempts to overburn with the Pioneer DVR-A04 weren't successful. The
drive kept locking up at the end of the project with 99min media.
- CD-Text Results
We created several AudioCDs with CD-Text enabled. Pioneer DVR-A04 can write/read
CD-Text without any problems.
- CloneCD Tests
CloneCD
v3.3.4.1 reports that the Pioneer DVR-A04 drive supports only SAO-RAW writing
mode. According to our tests, Pioneer DVR-A04 doesn't really support RAW writing
and rejects the CUE sheet file as the CloneCD software reports:
- 8cm mini CDs
The Pioneer DVR-A04 supports 8cm CDs without any problems.
Note: An 80mm disc cannot be used when the drive is mounted vertically. This
case remains even when an adapter is used. The drive does not support Non-Standard
discs such as Shaped or Biz Card size discs.
6. DVD Tests
Pioneer
DVR-A04 IDE DVD-R/RW - Page
6
DVD Tests
Pioneer DVR-A04 supports both 1X and 2X (CLV) writing speeds with DVD-R format.
As you may know the X factor in the DVD format is not 150Kb/s but 1385Kb/s
meaning that a full DVD-R (4.38GB) will take around 60mins to be written at
1X and half the time at 2X writing speed (30minutes). The DVD format is simpler
than the CD, since you have only "Mode1" tracks and "DAO"
writing mode.
- Writing Performance
We used Nero 5.5.7.8 and wrote the same amount of data for all Pioneer DVR-A03/A04,
Ricoh DVD+RW MP5120A and Panasonic LF-D311 drives. The results are listed in
the following table:
DVD Recording Tests
|
Drives
|
Writing Speed
|
Average Writing Time (min)
|
Pioneer DVR-A03 (DVD-R)
|
(2x)
|
28:22
|
(1x)
|
56:24
|
Pioneer DVR-104 (DVD-R)
|
(2x)
|
28:15
|
Pioneer DVR-104 (DVD-R)
|
(1x)
|
56:21
|
Pioneer DVR-A03 (DVD-RW)
|
(1x)
|
56:25
|
Pioneer DVR-104 (DVD-RW)
|
(1x)
|
56:18
|
|
|
|
Panasonic LF-D311 (DVD-R)
|
(1x)
|
56:24
|
Pioneer DVR-A04 took 28:15mins to write an almost full 4.7GB disc. The recording
time is better than that of the DVR-A03 (by 8secs). At the 1X writing speed,
the drive will take almost one hour (56:21), which is again better than the
DVR-A03. It's quite interesting that the drive needs less time with DVD-RW format
at 1X than with DVD-R media:
7. 2x DVD-R Compatibility
Pioneer
DVR-A04 IDE DVD-R/RW - Page
7
2x DVD-R Compatibility
We used several types of DVD-R media to see which media could handle 2x DVD-R
writing speeds according to the current DVR-A04 firmware revision. All branded
media from Panasonic, Maxell, Pioneer and TDK can be written at 2x without any
problems.
We also tried some DVD-R media from
- CDRecordable.com 4.7GB (no-name)
- Imation 4.7GB (branded)
but Pioneer currently doesn't support 2x writing speed with them. There are
many complaints from users about cheap DVD-R media that cannot be written at
2x. Pioneer's answer is that they plan to support more media with future firmware
upgrades, dependant upon the media passing through Pioneer's and the DVD Forum's
verification process.
Pioneer suggests the use of the following DVD-R media for 2X recording:
2X DVD-R recording compatible media
|
|
|
DVR-103
DVR-A03
|
DVR-104
DVR-A04
|
Hitachi Maxell, LTD
|
OK
|
OK
|
Mitsubishi Chemical Corporation (Verbatim)
|
OK
|
OK
|
Mitsui Chemicals, Inc.
|
OK
|
OK
|
Pioneer Video Corporation
|
OK
|
OK
|
TDK Corporation
|
OK*1
|
OK
|
Taiyo-Yuden Co. , LTD
|
|
OK
|
Matsushita Electric Industrial Co.,LTD (Panasonic)
|
|
OK
|
*1 Starting with firmware revision V1.65
|
|
As of March, 20, 2002
|
Pioneer says that not all the media produced by the above manufacturers is
2X compatible. To confirm whether or not the media intended for use is 2X DVD-R
compatible, ask at the point of purchase.
Pioneer has posted the following information explain the current situation
with "un-branded" DVD-R media
With the launch of the DVR-103 and DVR-A03 DVD-R/RW drives, Pioneer included
a feature to allow recording of DVD-R at 2X. This feature has been brought about
by Pioneer's own engineering initiatives. Within each drive there are media
specific optimizations called 'write strategies'. These write strategies are
tailor made for specific media, making 2X DVD-R recording possible.
Currently the specification set by the DVD Forum for DVD-R is 1X recording.
Pioneer was able to base its 2X DVD-R recording feature on this specification,
making it possible to include this benefit for its customers.
To make 2X DVD-R recording compatible for "General" media, the following
steps must be completed. First, the media must pass the DVD forum's verification
for 1X DVD-R. Secondly, with the cooperation of the media manufacturer, Pioneer
fine tunes the media for 2X recording. Only after passing through these stages
is the media considered 2X DVD-R compatible.
On some media 2X DVD-R recording may not be possible depending on the media's
release date, and due to the need to implement this development process. Unlike
high speed CD-R recording, 2X DVD-R recording requires optimization. Without
any optimization the possibility exists that the recorded media will lack the
desired playback quality. This process has been implemented in order to avoid
customer confusion over DVD-R media that is deemed not compatible with 2X recording.
The 2X DVD-R record feature is media specific. The record speed may default
to 1X depending on the media used.
Pioneer will endeavor to communicate this to the end user by making this
information available in instruction manuals, product packaging, and other methods
of communication. Along with the cooperation of media manufacturers Pioneer
will make every effort to increase the number of 2X record compatible DVD-R
media.
8. RW-Packet Writing Tests
Pioneer
DVR-A04 IDE DVD-R/RW - Page
7
HS-RW Writing Tests
We used Nero 5.5.7.8 for writing CD's with the maximum RW writing speed (4X)
for the Pioneer DVR-A04. Note that the test result from DVR-A03 comes with normal
CD-RW media:
The Pioneer drives need around 20mins to finish the task, due to its low
(4X) re-writing speed. The erase time is 50 secs, 3 seconds faster than the
previous model.
- CD Packet Writing Tests
We used Ahead InCD v3.21 for all Packet Writing tests. We used TDK
HS-CD/RW media and we formatted it. The formatted disc revealed 530mbs of free
space. We copied a 403 MB file (403.147 kbs) from a Hard Disk (on the same PC
as the writers) to the formatted RW media-using explorer (we dragged and dropped)
and we completed the test twice to eliminate possible time measurement faults
and user errors:
The Pioneer DVR-A03 supports only 2.4X writing and 2.8X reading speeds with
a packet written formatted RW disc.
- DVD-RW packet writing tests
Using a blank DVD-RW disc, you can format the disc with the
UDF 1.5 format and then use it like a normal CD packet-writing medium.
-Test Results
We used the same file/methodology that we are used for our CD packet-writing
test. The drive needs 5:01mins to write the file and 4:50mins to read it. That
can be translated in 0.98X writing and 1.00X reading (X factor = 1385Kb/s).
The erase time is also shorten to 2 minutes.
9. Conclusion
Pioneer
DVR-A04 IDE DVD-R/RW - Page
9
Conclusion
Positive (+):
|
Negative (-):
|
- Super CD-R/RW, DVD-R/RW combo drive
- Supports 2x writing DVD-R
- Supports 1x reading/writing DVD-RW
- Supports 8x writing CD-R and 8x re-writing* HS-CD/RW = 4x
- Performance is within the drive's specifications
- Supports reading of SubChannel Data (only 16bytes)
- Supports CD-Text (reading/writing)
- Low noise and CPU Usage whilst operating
- Drive includes fan to keep temperature down
- Initial price is lower than competitor DVD+R drives
|
- High Speed Re-writing has been limited
to 4x
- Doesn't seem to support overburning higher than 82mins
- Doesn't support DAO-RAW
- Doesn't support 2X DVD-R with all media
|
DVR-A04 is the second low-end DVD-R recorder from Pioneer. The company had
really dominated the market with the DVR-A03 recorder and the new model has
several improvements over the previous one. The biggest improvements are the
higher reading speeds and the supported buffer underrun protection for CD and
DVD formats. There is also support for HS-CD/RW format with 4x re-writing speed.
The DVD recording times also seem to be improved and a possible good price for
the drive will make it a successful buy, however not as much as the DVR-A03
series. Why? The answer is simple.
The main problem of the DVR-A04 is the new generation of DVD+R/RW recorders
that will hit the market in the same time frame. The DVD-R format has proven
'higher compatibility' with DVD desktop players than the new DVD+RW format.
However the DVD+R format promises the same and even higher compatibility than
DVD-R, something that makes things more complicated. Also the DVD+RW format
supports a higher recording speed of 2.4x. Of course no one yet has tested the
compatibility of a DVD+R disc, but soon we will have more info.
As a final word, we can say that Pioneer DVR-A04 will not disappoint its
potential buyer who wished for several improvements over the already successful
DVR-A03. Of course though, the desired 4x DVD-R recording speed is not yet implemented,
but after the summer something will come up. The drive's initial price will
be less than 600 Euros around Europe, and the "old" DVR-A03 price
will be even lower. Who said it's not the time to buy a DVD-R drive?