Thursday, January 18, 2018
Search
  
Submit your own News for
inclusion in our Site.
Click here...
Breaking News
Western Digital Expands Mid-Range Enterprise Air-based Hard Drives Offerings
Amazon Eyes the Advertising Business: report
European Regulators Approves Qualcomm's Acquisition of NXP, Subject to Conditions
Intel Says That Patches for Spectre, Meltdown Affect Newer Chips
Redbox Says Disney's Lawsuit is an Anti-competitive Behavior
Nintendo Releases Cardboard Accessories for Switch
IC Knowledge Outlines EUV, 7nm and 5nm Progress
Samsung Starts Producing First 16-Gigabit GDDR6
Active Discussions
Which of these DVD media are the best, most durable?
How to back up a PS2 DL game
Copy a protected DVD?
roxio issues with xp pro
Help make DVDInfoPro better with dvdinfomantis!!!
menu making
Optiarc AD-7260S review
cdrw trouble
 Home > News > Optical Storage > Copyrig...
Last 7 Days News : SU MO TU WE TH FR SA All News

Tuesday, April 01, 2003
Copyright is only half the answer...


Storage IT Toolbox reports "...As the Consumer Electronics Association joins 25 other companies & organizations in expressing their support for the Digital Media Consumers Rights Act, I'm reminded of a reader feedback complaining that fair use was just a cover for theft & piracy. The comment begs an important question which I attempted to address in my seminar talk at FORUM (Paris X): What is the fundamental role of rights such as copyright & fair use?

and continues "...While the concept of rights, particularly human & civil, are generally perceived as a relatively recent post-revolutionary phenomena, led ironically by the then newly formed American & French republics, other fundamental rights such as property have been a permanent fixture of human civilization. They, in fact, are what have allowed for two individuals, groups, governments,... to enter into transactions and trade goods. It's rights, not money, that makes the world go round.

Rights provide each party, the buyer as well as the seller, with a reasonable expectation that they will derive the anticipated benefits from the transaction. If I cannot defend my most basic property rights, have no recourse to a judicial remedy or confidence in the enforcement of those rights, I am much less likely to enter into transactions to acquire additional property. In kind, if I cannot reasonably expect compensation for the sell/trade/use of my property, I am more likely to hoard it. Economist would describe this as a market working sub-optimally, or at worst foreclosed.

In the music industry, we understand property rights all to well as our very livelihood depends on our ability to receive just compensation for the use of our works. In fact, the industry's primary argument in defense of copyright enforcement is the foreclosure of the market as creators and their representatives pull out. But as a music consumer, I also understand the importance of fair use rights.

For example, if I cannot have a reasonable expectation of being able to rip and encode a song from a legitimately purchased CD for use on my digital music player, I will have a greater reticence to purchasing the CD. I'll certainly balk at the obligation to pay for that digital track, especially if offered exclusively in a format not compatible with my chosen digital player. Nor am I likely to buy an e-book for which I am unable to make a back-up copy.

While the major labels have addressed many of these issues in the latest versions of MusicNet & pressplay, as well as licensing terms with other providers such as Listen & FullAudio, this was done reluctantly over a period of nearly 2 years and business decisions can be fickle. A major legal victory by the industry knocking-out p2p would most probably result in a quick retreat to the labels' original position of restrictive usage rules.

Legislation such as that introduced by Reps. Rick Boucher (D-VA) and John Doolittle (R-CA) is thus essential to provide consumers with the confidence to purchase digital music. Fair use is not a question of kids getting away with theft, but building the balanced rules necessary to build a market..."


Previous
Next
Pioneer DVR-A05 & DVR-105 Flashing Guide/FAQ        All News        Pioneer DVR-A05 & DVR-105 Flashing Guide/FAQ
Pioneer DVR-A05 & DVR-105 Flashing Guide/FAQ     Optical Storage News      Pioneer DVR-A05 & DVR-105 Flashing Guide/FAQ

Source Link Get RSS feed Easy Print E-Mail this Message

Related News
German Authorities Shut Down File-sharing Site
Youtube-mp3.org Site Shut Down
European Union's Top Court Rules That PirateBay's Operations Risks Breaking The Law
Microsoft Patent Describes Windows Ability To Detect and Block Pirated Content
Google, Bing Agree to Help U.K. Fight Pirate Sites
U.S. Trade Representative Calls Out Stream Ripping In Latest 'Notorious markets' Report
World's Largest Music Strem Ripping Site Faces Legal Action
MPAA Lists Piracy Sites in Around The World
U.S. Trade Office Releases Latest Notorious Markets List
Pirate Bay Back Online
Pirate Bay Co-founder Sentenced To 42 Months Imprisonment
Search Engines Play A role In Piracy: study

Most Popular News
 
Home | News | All News | Reviews | Articles | Guides | Download | Expert Area | Forum | Site Info
Site best viewed at 1024x768+ - CDRINFO.COM 1998-2018 - All rights reserved -
Privacy policy - Contact Us .